In the post-pandemic world, the workplace has undergone a seismic shift. Employees at every level have reevaluated what they want from their work, prioritizing purpose, flexibility, and well-being over traditional incentives. But while much attention has been paid to engaging and retaining frontline employees, one critical question remains: How do we approach executive compensation in this new era?
The old models—hefty salaries, performance bonuses tied to rigid metrics, and stock options—may no longer be enough to engage and inspire leaders. The pandemic revealed gaps in leadership priorities, highlighted the fragility of certain industries, and created a pressing need for executives to lead with resilience, adaptability, and empathy. To attract and retain these transformative leaders, organizations must rethink how they structure executive compensation.
Let’s explore why traditional approaches may be falling short and what innovative strategies can make compensation packages more relevant, motivating, and aligned with the expectations of today’s executives.
Why Traditional Executive Compensation Models Are Becoming Obsolete
1. Money Alone Doesn’t Motivate
While a competitive salary is still a cornerstone of executive compensation, research shows that financial incentives lose their power to motivate at higher income levels. Leaders who’ve already achieved financial security are increasingly driven by factors like purpose, impact, and legacy.
According to a 2024 Gallup survey, 78% of executives said they prioritize meaningful work and alignment with company values over pure monetary rewards.
2. The Shift Toward Long-Term Impact
The pandemic exposed the shortcomings of short-term performance metrics, like quarterly earnings or immediate stock price boosts, which often drive traditional executive bonuses. Leaders today are expected to focus on sustainability, innovation, and building resilient organizations—goals that require a long-term perspective.
Short-term compensation incentives can inadvertently discourage the forward-thinking decisions needed to navigate a world of constant disruption.
3. Employees Are Watching
In the post-pandemic workplace, transparency and fairness are top priorities for employees. Executive compensation that seems excessive or disconnected from organizational performance can breed resentment and disengagement among employees.
A 2025 report by Glassdoor found that 62% of employees believe their company’s executive pay is disproportionate to the value those leaders deliver. Organizations must align executive pay with broader workforce priorities to foster trust and engagement.
New Approaches to Executive Compensation
To engage and inspire today’s leaders, organizations need to think beyond traditional pay structures. Here are some innovative strategies that align with the values of the modern workplace.
1. Purpose-Driven Incentives
Nonprofit executives are often deeply motivated by purpose. Compensation tied to mission-based outcomes can both engage leaders and reinforce the organization's commitment to its goals.
What It Looks Like:
- Incentives tied to measurable mission impact, such as increasing the number of beneficiaries served, expanding programs, or achieving sustainability milestones.
- Bonuses linked to successfully securing grants or donations that support long-term organizational goals.
- Rewards for strategic accomplishments like forging impactful partnerships or scaling services sustainably.
Why It Works:
Mission-based incentives align compensation with the core values of the nonprofit, ensuring leaders remain focused on meaningful impact rather than purely financial results.
2. Well-Being and Flexibility Perks
Leaders, like all employees, have felt the strain of the pandemic. Burnout among executives is at an all-time high, making well-being and flexibility critical components of any compensation package.
What It Looks Like:
- Offering extended sabbaticals for executives to recharge and focus on personal growth.
- Including access to personalized health programs, executive coaching, or mental health resources.
- Structuring compensation to allow for flexibility, such as performance-based pay that doesn’t require a constant physical presence in the office.
Why It Works:
These perks recognize that leaders can only perform at their best when their well-being is prioritized, creating a more human-centered approach to compensation.
3. Profitability with a Twist
Stock options have long been a staple of executive pay, but they can sometimes encourage risk-averse behavior or focus too heavily on short-term gains. Organizations can rethink equity to drive more meaningful results.
What It Looks Like:
- Introducing long-term equity plans that reward sustained success over 5 to 10 years rather than quarterly results.
- Creating “mission-aligned equity” tied to achieving specific organizational objectives, such as market expansion, technological innovation, or employee engagement.
- Offering shared ownership models that align executive rewards with the financial well-being of employees.
Why It Works:
These approaches encourage long-term thinking, align executives’ interests with the company’s mission, and promote equity across the organization.
4. Customizable Compensation Packages
One-size-fits-all compensation models rarely reflect the unique needs and priorities of today’s leaders. Offering customizable options allows executives to choose rewards that align with their personal and professional goals.
What It Looks Like:
- Allowing executives to allocate their compensation among salary, bonuses, equity, and benefits based on their preferences.
- Offering tailored perks, such as childcare support, relocation assistance, or executive education programs.
- Providing options for executives to invest in their teams or departments as part of their compensation package.
Why It Works:
Customizable packages give leaders more control over their rewards, fostering satisfaction and loyalty.
5. Team-Based Rewards
Compensation doesn’t have to focus solely on individual performance. Team-based incentives can reinforce collaboration and align leadership goals with overall organizational success.
What It Looks Like:
- Awarding bonuses based on the collective performance of the executive team, such as achieving company-wide milestones or meeting employee engagement targets.
- Creating cross-functional reward programs that encourage leaders to work together on big-picture objectives.
Why It Works:
Team-based rewards promote alignment, collaboration, and a culture of shared accountability.
Challenges to Overcome
While these new approaches offer exciting possibilities, implementing them isn’t without challenges.
1. Balancing Transparency and Privacy
Striking a balance between transparent compensation practices and respecting executives’ privacy can be tricky. Open communication about how packages are structured can help build trust while avoiding unnecessary scrutiny.
2. Measuring Impact
Purpose-driven and long-term incentives require reliable metrics to assess success. Organizations must invest in tools and processes to measure progress effectively.
3. Aligning with Shareholders
Shareholders may resist compensation models that prioritize long-term goals over immediate financial returns. Leaders need to clearly communicate the value of these approaches to gain buy-in.
The Road Ahead
In this new era, executive compensation must reflect the changing values of both leaders and the organizations they serve. By prioritizing purpose, well-being, equity, and collaboration, companies can create compensation packages that do more than attract talent—they inspire leaders to drive meaningful change.
The ultimate goal? To align leadership rewards with the needs of employees, customers, and the broader community. In doing so, organizations can foster a culture of resilience, innovation, and shared success—one where leaders and their teams thrive together.
Latest posts by Tresha Moreland (see all)
- Rethinking Executive Compensation: New Approaches for a New Era - January 30, 2025
- The Metrics That Matter: Redefining Success in a Purpose-Driven Workplace - January 29, 2025
- The Future of Hybrid Work: Beyond the ‘Home vs. Office’ Debate - January 28, 2025
