Pages Navigation Menu

Insights. Influence. Results.

10 Steps To a Better Hire

10 Steps To a Better Hire

Put simply; talent matters. The problem is very few people actually possess the talent to identify talent. Identifying and recruiting talent requires a much broader skill set than screening a resume and having a set of standard interviewing questions to guide you. The issues of leadership, values, vision, culture, context etc., need to be creatively and intuitively addressed in the hiring process. If these issues are overlooked and/or misunderstood, there will be a heavy cost down the road.

Creating a talent advantage begins with smart hiring. That said, it never ceases to amaze me at the number of people who are charged with hiring who possess absolutely no skill at doing so. Smart leaders do more than just hire smart people – they have a smart hiring process and/or methodology. By following the 10 steps outlined below you won’t just make the hire, you’ll make the right hire:

  1. Definition: Make sure that you know exactly what you are looking for, both in terms of the job description, and the profile of the individual most likely to be successful in that role. If you can’t define who and what you’re looking for, you shouldn’t be looking.
  2. Timing: There is wisdom in the old axiom “hire slow and fire fast.” Don’t panic and end-up making a regrettable hire out of perceived desperation. Give yourself plenty of runway. You’ll be much better-off taking your time and making a good hire rather than using the ready, fire, aim methodology and end-up terming the new hire before they eclipse their probationary period.
  3. ABH: Always Be Hiring: Never let your organization be put behind the talent 8-ball, as great talent is rarely available on a moment’s notice. In the world of professional sports the search for talent often starts during the middle-school years, which is long before the potential talent being tracked by the scouts has matured. Your organization should always be on the look-out for great talent whether that talent is still in graduate school, in the military, working for competitors, or working outside the industry. Some of the best hires I’ve made over the years were executives that I spent months, and in some cases, years developing relationships with.
  4. Identify Your Talent Scout: Look for and identify the person within your organization who has the best nose for talent. Regardless of what position this person holds, get them involved in the process. If you don’t have a natural talent scout internally, seek outside assistance in the form of an advisor/consultant. Don’t turn your talent scout into just another corporate bottleneck, rather give them leverage by having them collaborate with outside recruiters. Outsourced recruiting is very effective and affordable if managed properly.
  5. Team Based Hiring: While I’m not generally in favor of management by committee, hiring based upon a team approach works very well. In a perfect world, a hiring team would consist of your HR manager (compliance), your internal and external talent scout (the gut-check), the direct supervisor over the position being hired for (competency, capability, and compatibility) and the senior executive who is the best at selling your organization (the closer). Hiring in a team-based fashion eliminates many of the typical mistakes that can be made in the hiring process.
  6. Values Based Hiring: You can either spend time finding employees who share your organization’s values, or deal with the brain damage of managing conflicts that arise due to opposing values. Smart companies focus on the former and not the latter. It simply isn’t necessary to compromise on core values to acquire talent. A new hire should desire to be part of your company for more than the ability to maximize immediate earning potential - they should be interested in your company because there is a sincere alignment of values and vision. Trust me when I tell you that compromises in this area, which often seem insignificant during the interview process, will become visibly and materially significant down the road.
  7. Hire Leaders: I have a basic premise when it comes to hiring – most companies get exactly what they deserve. When companies complain about a lack of leadership, or how difficult it is to identify leaders, my question is simply this: Why didn’t you hire a leader to begin with? Sure, leadership can be learned, but not everyone is willing to learn, and even if they are, education takes time and has a very real cost. Let me be clear, I’m not knocking leadership development initiatives – there is no perfect leader, and all leaders need to focus on development. What I am saying is development of an existing leader is faster, easier, and more effective than creating a leader.
  8. Cultural Fit: Culture matters – forget this and all other efforts with regard to talent initiatives will be dysfunctional, if not lost altogether. Don’t allow your culture to evolve be default, create it by design. The first step in cultural design is to be very, very careful who you let through the front door. People, their traits, attitudes, and work ethic (or lack thereof) are contagions. This can be positive or negative – the choice is yours. The old saying, “talent begets talent” is true.
  9. Pay for Talent: I cannot even begin to count the number of times I’ve witnessed companies pass over the right hire, or worse yet, not even look for the right hire because they let self-imposed financial constraints serve as a barrier precluding sound decisioning. I’ve actually personally observed HR managers filter better qualified candidates because they were a few thousand dollars outside the “top-end” of the salary range. It is precisely this type of thinking that will keep a company from being competitive in the market. To put it bluntly, you get what you pay for. Real talent produces real results, and is worth the investment. Always hire up where possible - find the right talent and then do what it takes to secure the services of said talent. You cannot afford not to invest in talent.
  10. Constantly Upgrade: You can hire the best talent in the world, but remember that “best” is a subjective evaluation largely measured within the context of a snapshot in time. Obsolescence can take root in anyone if growth and development are not focus points. Development needs to occur at every echelon of the workforce  - the top, middle, and bottom performance tiers. Top performers need to be stretched, mid-tier performers need to be challenged to up their game, and you should always look to upgrade the bottom 20% of your workforce. This can be done through training and development or via new hires. You need to ask yourself the following question: Who are the least productive members of your team? Why? Coach them to productivity or replace them – there is no third option.

Hiring is a blend of art and science. The reality is that those organizations that identify, recruit, deploy, develop and retain the best talent will be the companies who thrive in the future.

The following two tabs change content below.
Mike Myatt is a leadership advisor to CEOs and Boards, author of Leadership Matters, a Forbes Contributor, and is Managing Director at N2growth where he authors the N2growth Blog.

Latest posts by Mike Myatt (see all)


  1. Porn in the Workplace: More Often Than We Know | HR C-Suite - [...] a company employs those who view pornography, it creates a legal liability by allowing an offensive, sexually hostile [...]
  2. Applicant Flow: Where are the Qualified Candidates? | HR C-Suite - […] Another reason for this frustration is because these organizations have already or are currently hiring people to fill these…
  3. The “Wow!” Is In The Details | HR C-Suite - […] multi-task, prioritize, work through lunch, come in early, and stay late.  And, while we usually do a good job…
  4. Recruiting Top Talent: A Tricky Business | HR C-Suite - […] steps such as creating an engaging job description, posting the job efficiently, and interviewing candidates effectively, you can help…
  5. Are Your Recruiting Rules Working? | HR C-Suite - […] We would hire from the community over 50 people: guards, drivers, assistant nurses, nurses, logisticians, and an administrator to…
  6. Should Your Business Outsource Recruiting? | HR C-Suite - […] If you already have a fine tuned HR machine, why hire someone else to grade you on your functions?…
  7. Being Creative: 5 Ways to Land the Perfect Hire | HR C-Suite - […] and employees go. They get appointed for business progression, but they leave for greener pastures. Hiring the perfect candidate…
  8. Overwhelmed? 4 Ways to an Efficient Small Business | HR C-Suite - […] big. Don’t limit yourself in your ability to hire the best talent. The truth is many people have become disenfranchised…
  9. 3 Rising Benefits that Attract the Best Talent | HR C-Suite - […] pursuing new talent, especially in competitive industries, many companies have turned to innovative benefits packages […]
  10. 4 Ways Business Videos Could Improve the Corporate Culture | HR C-Suite - […] done in a strict manner. They need to be a good listener, should be able to make good judgement,…

Donate To Help Others

Donate to Doctors Without Borders

Donate to Doctors Without Borders

In a time when we can help others, we encourage a donation to Doctors Without Borders.

Check This Offer Out

Sign Up To Get Our Free Hot HR Trends Report

Also get: 

1) HR and Leadership strategy thought articles delivered to your inbox once a week;

2) Access to white papers and special reports as they become available;

3) Access to tools and resources;

4) Discount information from our partners. 


You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This